Layer 1
Northside Christian School - Westerville, OH - Head of School

Opportunity Profile

Head of School

Presented by Shepherd Staff

Consultant: Jake Rhoads
262.267.6550| Jake@shepherd.group

What you need to know most about this position:

The Head of School role at Northside Christian School in Westerville, OH represents a pivotal evolution in the life of a beloved, multi-generational institution. Northside is ready for a leader who can honor its deeply relational DNA while advancing its mission with clarity, courage, and strategic discipline. This role will require a unique blend of spiritual authority, executive acumen, and relational presence. The next Head of School will inherit a community marked by loyalty, prayerfulness, and a rich legacy of Christian formation, yet also one that is eager for organizational coherence, renewed direction, and a leader who can bring modern educational leadership practices into alignment with the school’s founding convictions.

This position carries both the weight and privilege of shaping the next era of growth for Northside. The new leader will be entrusted with helping refine governance structures, strengthening cross-department collaboration, mentoring a devoted faculty, and cultivating a mission-driven culture that is intentionally taught and consistently lived. They will have the rare opportunity to build on decades of faithfulness, restore healthy leadership rhythms, bring clarity to complex systems, and establish a sustainable executive structure that equips Northside not just for the next five years, but for the next fifty. This is a calling ideally suited for a leader who thrives at the intersection of spiritual formation, institutional development, and visionary leadership.



About Northside Christian School

Northside Christian School is a 50-year ministry extension of Calvary Bible Church in Westerville, Ohio, faithfully serving families across the Columbus area since 1971. Rooted in a commitment to Christ-centered education, Northside has shaped generations of students who carry its mission—“to learn, love, and live like Christ” - into their homes, communities, and vocations. The school’s legacy is reflected in its multi-generational continuity, with alumni returning as faculty, parents enrolling their children in the same classrooms they once sat in, and long-tenured teachers stewarding culture with devotion and depth. While deeply relational at its core, the organization is also standing at an important inflection point, ready to pair its heritage with renewed vision, strengthened leadership structures, and a more aligned organizational architecture. Northside offers the next Head of School a rare combination of history, heart, and readiness for intentional transformation.

Position Information:

Job Description

The Head of School serves as the chief executive and spiritual leader of Northside Christian School, responsible for guiding the institution’s mission, culture, academic excellence, and operational health. This leader will oversee the strategic direction of the school, ensuring alignment across faculty, staff, programs, and departments while cultivating a spiritually formative environment for students. The role includes leadership of the administrative team, partnership with Calvary Bible Church, engagement with families and the broader community, and stewardship of school-wide systems, governance alignment, personnel development, and organizational strategy. This individual will lead with pastoral presence, executive clarity, and disciplined follow-through, ensuring that Northside flourishes academically, spiritually, and organizationally.

Ideal Candidate Description

  • A Systems-Driven Executive Leader Who Can Build Organizational Structures
  • A Resilient Culture Curator Who Leads with Character, Conviction, and Courage
  • A Steadying Presence with Emotional, Relational, and Spiritual Authority
  • A Visionary Guide Who Can Realign from Maintenance to Sustainable Growth
  • A Cultivator of Mission-Centric Community, Leadership, and Excellence

Position History

The Head of School position at Northside Christian School emerges at a meaningful moment in the school’s story. For many years, Northside operated under a traditional Principal model supported by the steady leadership of Executive Director Jeff Peterson, whose longevity and pastoral presence provided the relational backbone and operational continuity the school needed through multiple seasons of change. Following the departure of the previous Principal, the school entered a transitional period under the capable interim leadership of Sharon Ross, who provided stability, reassurance, and organizational steadiness while the community discerned its next steps. This interim season revealed a growing clarity among faculty, families, church partners, and organizational leaders: the scope, complexity, and calling of the role had outgrown the title of Principal and required a more comprehensive, strategically empowered Head of School model. This change is not merely a rebranding but a forward-looking response to the school’s development, its maturing needs, and its desire to position the next leader to thrive. The new Head of School will step into a role shaped by decades of faithfulness, strengthened by an interim season of stability, and now poised for a leader with the vision, caliber, and executive instincts to guide Northside into its next chapter of growth, alignment, and mission-centered flourishing.

Shepherd Staff Observations:

Shepherd Staff spent time onsite at Northside Christian School interviewing leaders, staff, and critical church members to gain valuable insights about the church, the position, and the community. Here are our unbiased observations.

About the Organization

Northside Christian School is an institution marked by sincerity and devotion. Its strongest qualities are embedded in its people: faithful faculty who teach with conviction and affection, administrators who carry more than their job descriptions require, students who speak openly about their spiritual experience, and families who remain engaged and invested year after year. The school carries a depth of relational warmth that cannot be manufactured. It is the kind of community where people stay because they belong. There is a genuine spiritual attentiveness on campus and a shared belief in the school’s purpose, even as the community acknowledges the need for renewed direction.

At the same time, the school is standing on the threshold of meaningful development. Northside has the rare advantage of being both stable and ready for change. There is a collective desire for clearer systems, stronger leadership infrastructure, deeper alignment between mission and practice, and a fresh articulation of what it means to learn, love, and live like Christ. The next leader will not be stepping into resistance but into receptivity. The community is hopeful, expectant, and eager to move toward greater coherence, unity, and strength with the right leadership guiding the way.

The Northside Christian School community carries a rare combination of warmth, loyalty, and spiritual rootedness. Students speak candidly about their teachers as people who know them personally and care for their growth. Parents describe the school as a place where their children feel safe, supported, and surrounded by Christian influence. Alumni return because their formation at Northside shaped their spiritual and personal trajectories. This is a school where community identity is strong, heritage carries emotional weight, and families value the relational and spiritual distinctiveness that sets Northside apart.


About the Position

The Head of School role at Northside calls for a leader with both spiritual depth and executive stature, someone capable of honoring the school’s heritage while confidently guiding it into its next era of growth. This position is uniquely poised for a leader who brings organizational clarity, strategic foresight, and the capacity to build strong systems without diminishing the relational warmth that defines Northside. It requires a steady hand, a presence that inspires confidence, and a leader who can unify faculty, elevate leadership capacity, and cultivate a culture of shared ownership and mission alignment. The role is expansive, influential, and deeply meaningful, offering the opportunity to shepherd a beloved institution through the transition from stability to strategic advancement.

What the school needs in this season is a leader with strong agency and executive acumen, someone who naturally operates at a high altitude while maintaining relational accessibility. The ideal leader brings a refined ability to see the entire system, anticipate implications, and guide organizational architecture with clarity and conviction. This is a role for a builder who can distribute leadership, not absorb it; a strategist who can translate vision into plans; a culture-shaper who can influence with both courage and gentleness; and a spiritually grounded leader whose discernment, communication skill, and measured authority create trust quickly. The position offers the rare opportunity to steward both the heart and the health of an institution, bringing together executive leadership and spiritual shepherding in a way few roles can. It is a calling suited for someone who thrives in contexts where legacy, mission, and future potential converge.


About the Leadership

Northside Christian School benefits from deeply committed leadership marked by integrity, sincerity, and a genuine love for the community. The Executive Director has guided the school with sacrificial dedication and steady presence for many years, earning the trust of faculty, families, students, and church partners. Leadership at Northside is marked by sincerity, steadiness, and a deep commitment to the mission of Christian education. The individuals who steward the school bring warmth, faithfulness, and genuine pastoral care to their work. They are trusted voices within the community and serve with humility, integrity, and a consistent desire to do what is best for students, families, and one another. Their character is one of Northside’s greatest assets. This is a leadership culture where people serve with devotion and treat their roles as ministry, not merely responsibility. It provides an exceptional relational foundation for partnership with a new Head of School.

What makes this season especially hopeful is that this team also possesses the capacity and readiness for greater agency and alignment under strong executive leadership. Northside’s leaders demonstrate emerging strategic instincts, strong relational intelligence, and natural influence within the faculty. With clearer structures, aligned priorities, and a leader who can guide organizational vision, this group has the potential to become a highly cohesive and high-performing leadership body. They carry the raw material of future excellence: teachability, collaboration, loyalty, and a genuine desire to grow. The next Head of School will inherit a team that is not only deeply committed to the school, but eager to elevate its leadership acumen, embrace unified direction, and contribute meaningfully to a more empowered and strategically aligned future for Northside.

About the Community

Westerville, Ohio, is one of Central Ohio’s most desirable communities, offering a rare blend of warmth, stability, and opportunity that makes it an exceptional place for families and leaders to put down roots. Just north of Columbus, Westerville is known for its tree-lined neighborhoods, beautifully maintained parks, and a civic culture shaped by generosity and connection. It is a community where families stay for generations, where neighbors know one another, and where the pace of life feels balanced and grounded. With more than fifty miles of walking and biking trails, vibrant green spaces, and an award-winning recreation system, Westerville creates an environment in which personal well-being and family life can flourish. Residents enjoy the historic charm of Uptown Westerville, a lively district filled with locally owned restaurants, coffee shops, and boutiques that serve as a gathering place for community life throughout the year.

Yet what sets Westerville apart is its unique combination of suburban comfort and metropolitan access. Within minutes, residents can enjoy the cultural richness and economic vitality of Columbus, one of the nation’s fastest-growing regions with thriving sectors in education, technology, healthcare, and the arts. The area offers nationally recognized healthcare systems, numerous higher education institutions, and a growing landscape of innovation and opportunity. Despite this proximity to a major city, Westerville remains distinctly family-centered, safe, and inviting, with an ethos that values education, community involvement, and shared responsibility. For a Head of School, Westerville provides the ideal setting: a community that supports Christian education, champions family life, and offers the stability, relational warmth, and spiritual depth that allow a leader to build a meaningful life while guiding the next season of Northside Christian School’s mission.



Northside Christian School Information:

History of the Organization:

Northside Christian School was founded in 1971, and operates as an extension of Calvary Bible Church today. The school began with a vision to partner with Christian families in providing a Christ-centered education that cultivates academic excellence, spiritual formation, and discipleship. Over the decades, Northside has grown from modest beginnings into a respected, enduring K-12 institution. Its identity remains deeply tied to its church partnership and its multigenerational footprint, with alumni returning as educators, parents, and leaders. The relationship between the school and Calvary Bible Church continues to shape Northside’s ethos, mission, and spiritual culture.

Northside Christian School serves roughly 250 students across K-12. The school employs approximately 30 faculty members, supported by administrative and support staff who contribute to the daily life and operation of the school. Families represent a cross-section of the greater Columbus area who value a distinctly Christian education marked by relational care, small class environments, and a mission-centered approach to learning. The community reflects a blend of multi-generational continuity, diverse backgrounds, and shared commitment to Christ-centered formation.

Mission, Vision, & Core Values:

Mission

Partner with Christian families to edify and equip our graduates for a committed life of service in the world through Christ’s church.

Vision

Learn Christ. Love Christ. Live Christ.

Core Values

Quality Education, Redeemed Professional Faculty, Christian Environment, Grace-Filled Discipleship.

Northside Christian School Staff:


Jeff Peterson
Executive Director

Katie Ramirez
Admissions & Marketing Director


Search Process Steps

  1. 1.Shepherd Staff Candidate Screening
  2. 2.Questionnaire, Personality Profile
  3. 3.Shepherd Staff Video Interview
  4. 4.Shepherd Staff Video Interview with Spouse
  5. 5.Presentation to NCS Executive Director
  6. 6.Telephone/Video Interview with NCS Executive Director
  7. 7.Follow-up Video Conference with Search Team
  8. 8.Final Background Checks
  9. 9.Face-to-Face Visit at Church Location
  10. 10.Offer Extended
  11. 11.Start Date Set!


Community Information:

5 Things to do in and around Westerville, OH

1. Inniswood Metro Gardens

A beautiful 123-acre botanical garden with themed gardens, quiet walking paths, and wooded trails. Perfect for a relaxing stroll, photography, or a peaceful picnic.

2. Hoover Reservoir Park

A scenic spot for walking, biking, fishing, kayaking, or watching sunsets. The dam area has great views, and the surrounding trails offer plenty of nature time.

3. Uptown Westerville

A charming historic district with local restaurants, cafés, boutiques, breweries, and seasonal events. Great for a casual afternoon of exploring and people-watching.

4. Blendon Woods Metro Park

A large nature park nearby featuring hiking trails, a nature center, birdwatching areas, and family-friendly playgrounds. A good choice for a short outdoor getaway.

5. Hanby House Historic Site

A preserved historic home tied to Westerville’s role in music, abolition, and the temperance movement. A nice stop if you enjoy local history and architecture.


Interested in this Position?